Top Five Metal Roof Shingles of 2023: A Side-By-Side Comparison

Posted on June 20, 2023

Estimated Reading Time : 6 Min.

Share Now :
Top Five Metal Roof Shingles of 2023: A Side-By-Side Comparison

When it comes to roofing materials, we’re all familiar with traditional options like asphalt shingles and metal panels. However, advancements in the construction industry have paved the way for exciting innovations that combine the best of both worlds. Enter metal roof shingles, the perfect blend of superior durability and versatility.

In 2023, these cutting-edge roofing solutions are making waves, offering homeowners a unique combination of two popular roofing materials. 

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll unveil the top metal roof shingles of 2023, providing you with all the essential information you need to make an informed decision about upgrading your roof. Get ready to transform your home with a statement of style and reliability!

👉 What Are Metal Roof Shingles? 

Metal roof shingles are a type of roofing material that combines the durability and strength of metal with the classic look and versatility of traditional roofing materials, such as asphalt shingles and wood shingles.  

This innovative roofing solution is typically made from high-quality metal, such as aluminum, steel, or copper. 

Unlike regular metal roofs that have long, broader panels (standing seam roofing) or vertical ridges, metal shingles are formed into smaller, shingle-like shapes. Metal roof shingles come in a variety of styles, some resembling a classic asphalt shingle roof, and you can install them on various types of roofing systems. 

The core of these roofing materials is metal, so you need not worry about the durability of these shingles being compromised. 


👉 What Are The Factors To Consider When Choosing Metal Shingles? 

When it comes to selecting the perfect metal roof shingles for your home, there are several crucial factors to consider: 

  • Pricing 
  • Durability
  • Energy efficiency
  • Color options
  • Warranties
  • Metal type and gauge
  • Resistance capability to impact, fire, and algae

👉 What Are The Best Metal Roofing Shingles On The Market? 

If you’re considering upgrading your roof with the exceptional durability and aesthetic appeal of metal roof shingles, it’s important to know which options stand out from the rest. We understand that you might not have much time to do the research, so this is where our expertise can help you. 

At Division Kangaroof, we have quality roofers that keep up with the latest trends, and with our thorough research, we present to you some of the best options you can consider for your home. 

1. TAMKO MetalWorks®

Tamko metalworks®
Img Src: TAMKO MetalWorks®

First on our list is the TAMKO MetalWorks shingle range. TAMKO, the manufacturer of one of the best asphalt shingles, the Titan XT®, hits it out of the park with its exceptional metal roof shingle range. 

There are three varieties of MetalWorks shingles:

  • StoneCrest® Slate
  • StoneCrest® Tile (Metal shingles with the look of tile)
  • Astonwood ® (Metal shingles that resemble wood shake)

All three of these certainly pack a punch with durable design and double-stamped construction, but our favorite is the StoneCrest Slate shingles. They provide the look of real slate at a fairly reasonable price. These metal roofing products are available in eight vibrant colors, including slate gray and forest green. 

When it comes to the specifics, these metal roof shingles are constructed from heavy G90 steel, which is known for its exceptional strength and resistance to corrosion. This ensures that MetalWorks shingles can withstand even the harshest weather conditions, providing long-lasting protection for your home. 

Additionally, MetalWorks shingles are 100% recyclable and are rated highly by the Cool Roof Rating Council.

With MetalWorks shingles, you are not only guaranteed protection against the elements, but you will also be helping the environment. 

2. Milan Steel Shingles by McElroy Metal 

Milan steel shingles by mcelroy metal 
Img Src: Milan Steel Shingles by McElroy Metal

McElroy Metal is already a renowned name when it comes to metal roofing, so you should have no worries about the quality and finish of these roofing shingles. Milan steel shingles provide the best of both worlds, combining the timeless aesthetic appearance of shingles, slate, or shake with the remarkable benefits of metal roofing. 

Where these shingles really shine is in the aesthetics department. They look great and can enhance the curb appeal of any home. This is because they are available with a Kynar 500® color coating, otherwise known as PVDF, which is a resin-based coating that is durable and stays on for long periods of time. Not only that, but other metal shingle options, such as the slate and shake are provided by the company with this coating. 

3. DECRA Shingle XD

Decra shingle xd
Img Src: DECRA Shingle XD

When it comes to metal roofing shingles, one option that stands out from the rest is the DECRA Shingle XD line of stone-coated products. Meticulously designed with architectural precision, these shingles are engineered to provide a striking resemblance to asphalt shingles while delivering exceptional longevity. The key to their appeal lies in the distinctive thick-cut edges that create a sense of depth and dimension.

This low-maintenance stone-coated steel shingle is available in five colors that are sure to elevate the looks of any home, but the DECRA Shingle XD line offers more than just visual appeal, it boasts impressive durability that surpasses traditional asphalt shingles.

In fact, these stone-coated metal shingles have a life expectancy that’s two to three times longer than traditional asphalt roofing materials, ensuring that your roof will endure the test of time. This steel shingle is also Class A fire-rated and Class 4 impact resistant, the highest certification given.

Other options include the famous DECRA Shake and DECRA Shake XD, which offer the classic look of wood shakes with the durability of stone-coated steel. These are readily available in two colors, while the other two options are on a made-to-order basis. 

Though they are one of the best shingles around, their pricing can be on the higher side, especially if you consider other options on this list. 

4. Classic Metal Roofing Systems 

Classic metal roofing systems
Img Src: Classic Metal Roofing Systems

Classic Metal Roofing Systems is a renowned name in the metal roofing industry. Their premium offering, the Oxford Shingle, is sure to improve your roofing system. 

If you are a homeowner who values the timeless charm of your home and wants a roofing solution that will stand the test of time, then look no further than this metal shingle. While most of the shingles we have featured are made from steel, Oxford is built from aluminum which is flexible and requires low maintenance.

Crafted by the experts at Classic, this aluminum roofing panel is designed to capture the look of composition shingles, all while harnessing the undeniable advantages of metal roofing.

One of its standout features is its clean and simple lines, seamlessly blending with any architectural style. Whether your home boasts a classic design or embraces a more modern aesthetic, these shingles will effortlessly complement your property. 

5. EDCO Infiniti® Shake Shingles

Edco infiniti® shake shingles
Img Src: EDCO Infiniti® Shake Shingles

Last but not least is EDCO’s Infiniti® Textured Shake. These roof shingles are an evolution in the stone-coated steel roofing industry. They feature the company’s proprietary thermal-fused particle technology that helps provide a textured panel that can offer great durability. 

This metal roof shingle is available in nine beautiful colors, so you won’t feel limited and can really get what you’re looking for. Also, these colors are made with PVDF technology, meaning the color granules are resin based and will not peel or crack. This is the reason why EDCO is able to offer a 40-year fade protection warranty for this shingle.

When it comes to functionality, this metal shingle is fire-resistant, impact-resistant, and mold and mildew resistant. The company also provides a wind warranty of up to 160 mph. Apart from the Infiniti Textured Shake, you can also consider the EDCO ArrowLine® Shake roofing shingle. This line of metal shingles features robust metal panels that provide the look of wood shakes and is available in 17 color options. 

👉 Experience the Beauty and Durability of Your New Metal Roof: Schedule Your Installation Now

When it comes to installing a metal shingle roof, you want to ensure that the job is done right by experienced professionals. That’s where our team of experts comes in. As the leading metal shingle installers in Cornelia, GA and surrounding areas, we have the knowledge, skills, and expertise to deliver exceptional results. We install durable roofing materials that offer protection and energy efficiency.

Don’t settle for anything less than the best, contact us today at (706) 778-3516 and choose our reputable team for your next roofing project.

Skip to content